dark_administrator: (Default)
dark_administrator ([personal profile] dark_administrator) wrote in [community profile] dark_agenda2012-09-02 04:01 pm

Kaleidoscope 2012: List of Ineligible Fandoms, Characters, and People

Hello doers of darkness, thank you for your input regarding issues about dispute and fandom eligibility that we have posted at Dispute deadline reminder and feedback for our rarity policy and Kaleidoscope Disputes! We understand your concerns about not having enough fandoms to offer and request, your desires to include as many fandoms and participants as possible, and your wishes to increase the numbers of artworks, stories or vids in fandoms with low numbers of one or two fanwork types but not others, and we will revisit the issue when we plan for the next challenge, including gathering new fanwork data and modifying our rarity criteria based on the new data if necessary. However, because Kaleidoscope is a multimedia challenge, we believe it is important to consider rarity across all media and have decided to uphold the rarity criteria for all types of fanworks this year. We thank you for your understanding!

We have re-added Blue Beetle (Comics) as an eligible fandom with Jaime Reyes (2011) and Paco Tejas (2011) as the qualifying characters for Kaleidoscope under the consideration of a series reboot with Ig Guara at the artistic realm, and we have added Sengoku BASARA 3 as an eligible fandom under the consideration that it meets our rarity criteria and qualifies for our challenge while Sengoku BASARA as a top-level franchise do not. We continue to welcome your input on these matters.

Below is a list of fandoms, characters, and people that are considered ineligible for Kaleidoscope:

Ineligible Fandoms


The following fandoms are considered ineligible because we believe the source does not contain any creator(s) who identify as chromatic:
  • Attack The Block: Joe Cornish
  • Beasts of the Southern Wild: Benh Zeitlin, Lucy Alibar
  • Bel Dame Apocrypha: Kameron Hurley
  • Day Break: Paul Zbyszewski
  • Island of the Blue Dolphins: Scott O'Dell
  • Lions of Al-Rassan: Guy Gavriel Kay
  • Luther (TV): Neil Cross
  • Prince of Egypt (1998): Brenda Chapman, Nicholas Meyer, Philip LaZebnik, Simon Wells, Steve Hickner
  • Relic Hunter (TV 1999): Gil Grant
  • Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: Michael Piller, Rick Berman
  • Sunshine (2007): Danny Boyle
  • The Spiritwalker Trilogy: Kate Elliott
  • Tortilla Flats: John Steinbeck
  • Women of the Otherworld: Kelley Armstrong
  • Zorro: Johnston McCulley

The following fandoms are considered ineligible because we believe the source does not contain any characters that are coded as chromatic:
  • ダンタリアンの書架 (Dantarian no Shoka) (Mystic Archives of Dantalian)

The following fandoms are considered ineligible because we believe they do not meet one or more of our rarity criteria:
  1. less than 1,500 English-language stories on major multifandom archives;
  2. less than 15,000 artworks, 100 podfics and 350 vids (in any languages) on major multifandom archives;
  3. no dedicated fandom-specific challenge that has run annually for more than two years in a row;
  4. no dedicated fandom-specific archive or community that has more than 1,500 fanworks.

  • 青の祓魔師 (Ao no Ekusoshisuto) (Blue Exorcist): Ao no Exorcist has 31,870 Ao no Exorcist results and 20,617 Blue Exorcist results at deviantART and 53,261 artworks at pixiv
  • あずまんが大王 (Azumanga Daiō): Azumanga Daioh has 1,268 AMVs at AnimeMusicVideos.Org
  • DARKER THAN BLACK -黒の契約者- (Dākā Zan Burakku -Kuro no Keiyakusha-): Darker Than BLACK has 15,204 AMVs at AnimeMusicVideos.Org and 19,754 results at deviantART
  • ハートキャッチプリキュア! (Hātokyacchi PuriKyua!) (HeartCatch PreCure!): HeartCatch Pretty Cure! has 24,330 artworks at pixiv
  • けいおん! (Keion!) (K-On!): K-On! has 408 AMVs at AnimeMusicVideos.Org, 160,766 results at deviantART under Fan Art and 81,067 artworks at pixiv
  • 黒子のバスケ(Kuroko no Basuke) (Kuroko's Basketball): Kuroko no Basket has 96,986 artworks at pixiv
  • 魔法少女まどか☆マギカ (Mahō Shōjo Madoka Magika) (Puella Magi Madoka Magica): Madoka Magica has 26,351 results at deviantART and 118,591 artworks at pixiv
  • もののけ姫 (Mononoke-hime) (Princess Mononoke): Princess Mononoke has 800 AMVs at AnimeMusicVideos.Org
  • おおきく振りかぶって (Ōkiku Furikabutte) (Big Windup!): Oofuri has a dedicated fandom-specific challenge running for two years, e.g. http://archiveofourown.org/collections/OofuriExchange2010, http://archiveofourown.org/collections/OofuriExchange2011
  • Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt (パンティ アンド ストッキング ウィズ ガーターベルト) (Panti ando Sutokkingu wizu Gātāberuto): Panty & Stocking with Garterbelt has 17,450 results at DeviantART
  • 千と千尋の神隠し (Sen to Chihiro no Kamikakushi) (Spirited Away): Spirited Away has 525 AMVs at AnimeMusicVideos.Org, 24,435 results at deviantART and 2,195 stories at FanFiction.net
  • 少女革命ウテナ (Shōjo Kakumei Utena) (Revolutionary Girl Utena): Revolutionary Girl Utena has 718 AMVs at AnimeMusicVideos.Org
  • スマイルプリキュア! (Sumairu PuriKyua!) (Smile PreCure!): 34,438 artworks at pixiv


Ineligible Characters


The following characters or people are considered ineligible because we believe they do not identify or are not coded as chromatic:

FAKE
  • Berkeley Rose
  • Carol "Cal" Baker
  • Diana Spacey
  • Drake Parker
  • Jemmy J. "J.J" Adams

Petshop of Horrors
  • Chris Orcot
  • Jill
  • Leon Orcot

Trapped in the Closet by R. Kelly
  • Bridget


Our post on clarifications on tagging conventions and source eligibility provides some more insights on why some fandoms and characters have been considered as ineligible for Kaleidoscope. However, If you believe any of above fandoms and characters have been rejected in error, or if a fandom or character that you've nominated does not appear in the above ineligible list or the Kaleidoscope 2012 Nominations list (and our Kaleidoscope 2012 Nominations spreadsheet for reference), please let us know!

Happy belated Hari Merdeka & Independence Day (Trinidad and Tobago)!

This entry is posted at Dreamwidth and LiveJournal, as well as linked on Tumblr, and you may comment at any platform.